Put the Swing Back in Your Step
Less is More With Minimally Invasive Hip Surgery
By Mark W. Woolf, M.D.
Osteoarthritis of the hip is a painful condition. Most people with hip arthritis have difficulty walking, climbing stairs, and performing routine daily activities. They often feel pain in the groin, thigh, and buttocks and have referred pain in the knee causing many to walk with limps.
The condition can develop as the result of an injury or other developmental abnormalities of the hip, but most people develop arthritis as a result of lifelong wear and tear.
Physical therapy and gentle, supervised yoga are often useful, bringing stability and lubrication to the hip joint as well as stretching and strengthening surrounding muscles, which tend to tighten with joint instability. Women, in particular, tend to walk with the tailbone tilted backward, which keeps the lower back arched. Anti-inflammatory medications and nutritional supplements such as glucosamine may also provide some relief, while weight loss can decrease stress on all of the joints.
Treating Osteoarthritis of the Hip
Physicians may recommend hip-replacement surgery. Osteoarthritis of the hip is the most common diagnosis that leads to hip replacement, and here, too, there is more than one alternative, including minimal incision hip replacement surgery.
Conventional hip replacement involves making a 10-inch to 12-inch incision in order to reach and repair the hip. Minimally invasive surgery is performed through one or two smaller incisions.
A single, minimally invasive hip incision may measure only 3 inches to 6 inches, depending on the size of the patient and the difficulty of the procedure. This incision is usually placed over the outside of the thigh.
Muscles and tendons are split or detached to a lesser extent than in the traditional hip replacement operation, and these are routinely repaired after placing the implants to help healing and prevent hip dislocation.
Two-incision hip replacement, meanwhile, involves making a 3-inch to 4-inch incision over the groin for placement of the socket and a 3-inch to 4-inch incision over the buttock for placement of the stem. The two-incision procedure usually adds 30 to 45 minutes of surgical time compared to traditional hip-replacement surgery.
“Low-Wear” Hip Replacements
Minimally invasive knee replacement can mean smaller scars and a quicker recovery than traditional total hip replacement. “Low-wear" hip replacements use all metal bearing surfaces that show low wear rates after more than 30 million steps — or the equivalent of approximately 30 years of use.
Article Continued
The artificial implants used in the minimally invasive hip replacement procedures are the same as those used for traditional hip replacement. Specially designed instruments are needed in order to prepare the socket and femur and place the implants properly. Implantation of the artificial hip is the same, but the extent of soft-tissue dissection is less than with longer incisions.
Still, the decision to have a minimally invasive hip replacement requires a thorough evaluation and discussion with the operating surgeon about risks and benefits. Not all patients are candidates for this technique.
Benefits of Less Invasive Procedures
Candidates for the less-invasive procedures are typically thinner, younger, healthier, and more motivated for quick recovery than the average hip-replacement candidate. Some surgeons will not consider the procedure for obese patients or those with dense musculature. Potential benefits of less-invasive hip replacement include less pain from the incisions, which are more cosmetic in appearance; less muscle damage; and shorter hospital stays.
Hospital stays average three to four days for traditional hip replacement, and many patients require extensive rehabilitation afterward. With less-invasive procedures, the hospital stay may be as short as two days. Most patients are also able to bear full weight on the operated leg within 24 hours, and crutches or other walking aids are usually used for the first few post-operative weeks.
Computer assisted implant placement technology is advancing as experience with smaller incision surgery grows. More sophisticated technology will lead to more effective hip reconstruction. In addition, new implant designs and materials are being developed to facilitate minimally invasive hip surgery and prolong the replacement lifespan.